Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Will's avatar

I'm a big fan of the 5% of gear reviews which are like this -- real people talking about their real world experience with gear. And then if they can write well and have a sense of humor, bonus! So thank you Holly. Infinitely valuable -- and INTERESTING (even if I don't have a need for any of the gear reviewed, gives me a deeper understanding of the whole experience of getting out an hunting from someone else's perspective).

Expand full comment
Phillip Loughlin's avatar

Good stuff... but did I read that right? $1100 for waders? Holy sheep shit!

No new gear reviews from me this year...

Spent most of my deer season in 30+ year old Cabela's "polar fleece" gear. It hasn't been available for ages in the catalog, which doesn't surprise me. Seriously, how can you keep selling stuff if the stuff you sell lasts the better part of a lifetime? It's not quite as waterproof as it once was, and the bibs fit a little more snugly than they did all those years ago... but it's quiet and comfortable.

Pretty much the same story for duck gear.

My waders are the same (Cabela's?) 3mm neoprene stockingfoot waders I bought in 1996, my first season hunting in CA, after I realized that the heavy duty Hodgeman canvas waders were way too hot for hiking all the way across the refuge. They busted brush at Delevan, crawled through cockleburrs at Grizzly Island, and slogged through the Mendota mud for the whole time I hunted in CA. They were still solid and dry while I was standing up to my chest in the Northeast Cape Fear a couple weeks ago.

I've still got a couple Rubbermaid totes full of clothing and gear that was sent for review back in the day. As I recall, most of it was pretty decent. I did really like the Predator camo pattern when it came out. I do sort of miss getting new stuff to play with, but I don't think my honest reviews were always what the manufacturers and marketing teams wanted to see. I'm glad to see you're still giving it to us straight.

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts